Energy Transformation
Sample Lesson for Grades 4-8
Dennis W. Sunal
The University of Alabama
Tuscaloosa, Alabama
Alternative Conceptions Addressed by the Lesson Plan:
Energy is not measurable.
Energy transformations involve only one form of energy at a time and only if they have perceivable effects. For example, transformation of motion energy to heat energy (air friction) is usually not obvious because there is no observable temperature increase.
Lesson Goal: To allow students to investigate, develop inferences, and differentiate between the concepts of motion energy and heat energy, and the part played by friction in the transformation process.
Prerequisites: Can measure temperature to the nearest two degrees with a thermometer.
Exploration
Objective: The students will investigate the effects of motion on an object.
Materials: For each group:
Two baby food jars filled 1/2 full of sand
Two thermometers
Newspaper to cover desks or tables
Paper towels
Paper to make a bar graph and for recording
results
Procedure:
A. Tell the students that you are going to give them a thought problem. Have them discuss and write their answer on a sheet of paper. "You are riding in a car traveling down the interstate highway. The driver takes his foot off of the gas but doesn’t put his foot on the brake. The car comes to a stop on the side of the road. Why does the car stop?"
B. Place the students in groups of four and assign roles: materials manager, two timers/recorders, and one helper. All students will also serve as shakers.
C. Describe materials and instructions needed for student groups to carry out the activity of shaking jars containing sand at different rates and times. Discuss safety precautions relating to glass jars and thermometers.
D. Key question: What happens to the material inside a jar when you shake it? Draw and describe a jar one-half full of sand after it has been shaken for five minutes.
E. Provide each group of students with two baby food jars half-full of sand, newspaper, and a thermometer. Tell the students to wrap each jar with a piece of paper towel folded over several times to form a strip about two inches in width. This will provide insulation to keep the jars from being warmed by hands..
F. Ask the students to measure and record the temperature of the sand in each jar. Have the students examine the contents of the jar. Ask the students to infer what will happen to the contents of the jars if they are shaken for a long time. Have the students record their inferences.
G. Next, ask the students to close each jar tightly and to shake each jar for six minutes. One jar should be shaken rapidly. The other jar should be shaken moderately. The students in the group can take turns during the shaking process. Each student should shake the jar for one minute at a time.
H. After shaking, the students should immediately put thermometers into the jars. After sixty seconds, they read the thermometers. While waiting, the students the students can examine the the contents of the jar.
I. Ask the groups to report their results to the whole class. Help them communicate the results of their activities using tables and/or bar graphs to justify their conclusions.
Evaluation: Collect the students’ responses to the thought problem in "A" above. Evaluate them considering the type and extent of knowledge expressed. Evaluate group skills by assessing whether all participated equally in the activity.
Invention
Objective: The students will investigate a variety of materials and determine that the heat energy of an object can be changed by transforming motion energy into heat through friction.
Materials: For learning stations:
Small wood block (about the size of an ice cube) for each group
Ice cube for each group
Hammer
A dozen three to four inch nails
Six large boards (a one foot long, 2 inches by 4 inches board)
Wax paper
Seven pieces of sandpaper (8 1/2 inches by 11 inches)
Paper towels
Paper for recording results
Procedure:
A. Place the students in groups of four and assign roles: materials manager, readers/observers (two students), and recorder.
B. Have them discuss the key question from the Exploration in their groups. During the discussion introduce the alternative conception that the energy of motion from the hand caused the sand particles to move. The motion of the sand particles bumping against each other is called friction. The friction of the sand, stopping the motion of the sand, created heat.
C. Ask each group to perform the following activities at learning stations. Instructions for each station will be given on a laboratory guide available at the station.
Station 1: Slide a small block of wood and an ice cube across a sheet of sandpaper. Each member of the group should do the task. Discuss what happened.
Station 2: This station will involve using one large piece of wood, two books, and a piece of wax paper. Put the two books on top of the wood and push the wood along the floor. Then, pile the wood and the two books on top of the wax paper and push it along the floor. Draw and describe what happened each time.
Station 3: Take two large pieces of wood and rub them together as hard as possible fifteen or more times. Every member of the group should feel both pieces of wood afterwards. Discuss what happened when you carried out the activity.
Station 4: For this station you will need two boards and one piece of sandpaper. You will use the sandpaper on just one of the boards. Rub a piece of sandpaper fifteen times across a large wood board. Every group member should feel the board. Compare the board that was just rubbed with sandpaper to the board that was not rubbed with sandpaper.
Next, rub the sandpaper thirty times across the large wood board. Every group member should feel the board again. Feel a board that has not been just rubbed with sandpaper. Compare how both boards feel.
Station 5: In this station you will use a hammer, a nail, and a large board. Put the board on the floor and carefully pound the nail about halfway into the it. Discuss safety precautions relating to use of the hammer. Use the claws of the hammer to pull out the nail. Every member of the group should feel the nail. Then, discuss how it felt.
D. Lead a whole group discussion concerning motion, friction, and its effects. Student participation should include evidence from the learning stations and other experiences they have had with friction. The discussion should lead students to draw the conclusions that some of the energy of motion is transformed into heat energy in the objects involved and the greater the amount of friction, the more heat energy is transformed from the energy of motion.
E. As a closure, state that the greater the energy of motion the greater the heat energy produced. The rise in temperature of the thermometer indicates that a transfer of energy took place. The motion energy provided to the grains of sand or wood in the station activities was transformed as a result of friction, into increased heat energy in each grain of sand and in the wood.
Evaluation: Ask each member of the groups to write out a summary of the actions undertaken by group members at one of the stations. Each member should address a different station.
Expansion
Objective: The students will investigate and describe the chain of events by which motion energy is transformed into heat energy in an everyday situation.
Materials: For problem stations (as possible, ask the students to bring in these items)
Bicycle pump
Bicycle tire
Bicycle
Shoe
Kite
Lunch tray
Toy car
Procedure:
A. Provide each group of four students with problems written on three inch by five inch cards. Ask each group to perform the problem situation if possible. Whether or not they can act out the situation, they are to think about the problem and describe the chain of events by which the energy of motion in the problem becomes transformed into heat energy possessed by the objects involved. Write the key questions on the board. For each situation draw and describe "What is moving?" "What becomes warm?" and "How did the energy of motion become heat energy in the object?"
Problem 1: Your group must pump a bicycle tire for three minutes. After three minutes, feel the pump and the bicycle tire. Discuss the answers to the key questions.
Problem 2:
You are riding in a car traveling down the interstate highway. The driver takes his foot off of the gas but doesn’t put his foot on the brake. The car comes to a stop on the side of the road.
Discuss the answer to the key questions. You may use the toy car to act out the problem.
Problem 3:
A boy is riding a bicycle and stops it using hand brakes.
Discuss the answers to the key questions.
Problem 4:
A kite is flying in the sky in a strong wind. You notice smoke from a fire blowing into the kite. When it passes the kite, the smoke moves slowly and in swirls.
Discuss the answers to the key questions.
Problem 5:
For lunch today, you put pizza and french fries on your tray and slid the tray on the counter to the cashier.
Discuss the answers to the key questions.
D. Summarize the lesson by stating that when we started the activities, the students may not have been able to tell the difference between the words motion energy and heat energy, and the part played by friction in the transforming one to the other. The activities with sand in jars, stations, and problems should help them in applying these ideas successfully in your everyday lives. By observing events where something in motion is being heated, they should be able to identify the "source of friction" and apply the terms "motion energy" and "heat energy." Whether they are talking about bicycles or in-line-skates they should be able to use the idea of heat energy being transformed from motion energy.
Evaluation: Ask the students to respond to the following situations. First,
a girl is riding her bicycle and stops by dragging her feet.
Write out your the answer to this question: "What is moving?" "What becomes warm?" and "How did the energy of motion become heat energy in the object?" Second,
you are pushing a brick six feet along on a waxed tile floor, an unpainted cement floor, and through dirt on the playground.
"On which of these will more heat be created?"
Write out your the answer to this question. Evaluate the answers to these questions based on their appropriate application of the concepts motion energy and heat energy, and the part played by friction in the transforming one to the other. A performance checklist will be applied.
Level of Performance
1. May Identify heat as a result of the action and the source of friction in one or both situations. Does not identify or apply energy transformation as the cause of the actions observed.
2. Identifies heat as a result of the action and the source of friction. Identifies the reduction in motion energy and increase in heat energy variables in each situation. Does not apply energy transformation as the cause of the actions observed.
3. Identifies heat as a result of the action and the source of friction. Identifies the reduction in motion energy and increase in heat energy variables in each situation. Applies the idea of transformation of energy as the source of heat.
Some examples of people who made significant contributions to the physical sciences, but have been underrepresented in the mass media are listed in Figure 1 along with their major contributions. Additional information can be found in library references such as an encyclopedia. The book Nobel Prize Women in Science: Their Lives, Struggles, and Momentous Discoveries by S. McGrayne (1993) is one resource example. An added Expansion activity to most any physical science energy lesson would be to read a curent newspaper item on the contribution of a related energy scientist or use of energy science concepts by members in the community to make him or her seem more real. Older students could create library research reports and short plays on the contributions of these underrepresented scientists.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Figure 1
Scientists are Diverse!
Some Who Have Contributed to Our Knowledge of Physical Science
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Arnald of Villanova
He was an alchemist who worked with tinctures in Spain.
Callinicus
In Egypt, he explained the nature of combustion.
Har Khorana
An Asian American from India who invented the first artificial gene.
Tsai Lun
He invented paper in China.
Dorothy Wrinch
Working in Argentina, she found that the amino acids are where genes have their specific coding.
Benjamin Banneker
An African American who carried out research with honeybees and with a wooden striking clock.
Marie Curie
A Polish woman who discovered radium and polonium and receive the Nobel Prize for her work.
Bertha Lamme
She worked with the theory and design of motors and generators in the USA.
Lewis Latimer
He was an African American who developed the carbon filament for the electric light bulb.
Samuel Ting
An Asian American who discovered the J particle in the atom.